Skyscanner

Cheap Flights from New York (NYCA) to Montego Bay (MBJ)

Travellers and cabin class

Compare New York to Montego Bay flight deals

Find the cheapest month or even day of the year to fly to Montego Bay

Book the best Montego Bay fare with no extra fees

Flight deals from New York to Montego Bay

Looking for a cheap last-minute deal or the best return flight from New York to Montego Bay? Find the lowest prices on one-way and return tickets right here.
Montego Bay.$413 per passenger.Departing Tue, 27 May, returning Sat, 31 May.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Tue, 27 May, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Sat, 31 May, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $413, select.
Montego Bay.$472 per passenger.Departing Mon, 2 Jun, returning Sat, 7 Jun.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Mon, 2 Jun, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Sat, 7 Jun, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $472, select.
Montego Bay.$506 per passenger.Departing Wed, 9 Jul, returning Sat, 12 Jul.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Wed, 9 Jul, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Sat, 12 Jul, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $506, select.
Montego Bay.$519 per passenger.Departing Tue, 28 Oct, returning Wed, 5 Nov.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Tue, 28 Oct, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Wed, 5 Nov, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $519, select.
Montego Bay.$519 per passenger.Departing Tue, 7 Oct, returning Wed, 15 Oct.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Tue, 7 Oct, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Wed, 15 Oct, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $519, select.
Montego Bay.$519 per passenger.Departing Tue, 23 Sep, returning Wed, 1 Oct.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Tue, 23 Sep, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Wed, 1 Oct, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $519, select.
Montego Bay.$519 per passenger.Departing Wed, 12 Nov, returning Tue, 18 Nov.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Wed, 12 Nov, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Tue, 18 Nov, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $519, select.
Montego Bay.$519 per passenger.Departing Tue, 9 Sep, returning Wed, 17 Sep.Return flight with Spirit Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from New York LaGuardia on Tue, 9 Sep, arriving in Montego Bay.Inbound indirect flight with Spirit Airlines, departs from Montego Bay on Wed, 17 Sep, arriving in New York LaGuardia.Price includes taxes and charges.From $519, select.

Find the cheapest month to fly from New York to Montego Bay

We’re always keeping an eye on fares, so you can find the best one in seconds. It looks like New York to Montego Bay flights are currently cheapest in May.
May
from $413
Jun
from $472
Jul
from $506
Aug
from $595
Sep
from $519
Oct
from $519
Nov
from $519
Dec
from $660
Jan
from $653
Feb
from $662
Mar
from $660
Apr
from $1,616

Direct flights from New York to Montego Bay

New York to Montego Bay: Alternative routes

Compare routes from New York to Montego Bay below. You may find an airport to fly into that's cheaper, faster, or easier than Montego Bay.

New York to Montego Bay: Flight information

The things to know before you go.
Cheapest flight found$413
Cheapest month to flyMay
Average flight time4 hrs, 6 mins
Most popular airlinejetBlue
Average flights per week61

Finding cheap flights from New York to Montego Bay: Frequently asked questions

The best price we found for a return flight from New York to Montego Bay is $413. This is an estimate based on information collected from different airlines and travel providers over the last 4 days and is subject to change and availability.
4 hours and 6 minutes is the average flight time from New York to Montego Bay.
jetBlue, American Airlines and United fly direct from New York to Montego Bay.
As of May 2025, there are 61 flights per week flying from New York to Montego Bay.
The cheapest month to fly from New York to Montego Bay is usually May 2025.
After crunching the numbers on our flight calendar, we found that it is currently cheapest to fly from New York to Montego Bay Airport on Tuesday, 27 May 2025.
Yes – the average flight time is 4 hours and 6 minutes.
We show every price from over 1,200 airlines and travel agents, comparing them all so you don’t have to. If you know you want to fly to Montego Bay but you’re not ready to book, set up a Price Alert. We’ll track prices for you, and let you know when they rise or fall.
We crunched all the numbers in our flight calendar and it looks like the cheapest time to book a flight to Montego Bay is around 40 days in advance, so don’t leave your flight to the last minute.

Travelling from New York to Sangster International Airport (MBJ): what you need to know

  • When searching for your flight from New York to Sangster International Airport (MBJ), there's a good range of airports you can take off from. Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR), John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) and LaGuardia Airport (LGA) are among New York's main terminals.

  • Around 4 hours 1 minute is how long you can expect to be travelling on a direct flight from New York to Sangster International Airport.

  • Montego Bay is 1 hour behind New York. Sangster International Airport is located in Montego Bay, which operates on the UTC-5 timezone.

  • With 79 direct weekly flights between the two airports, Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) to Sangster International Airport (MBJ) is the busiest route. JetBlue operates the earliest flight at 05:20. If you prefer to get more out of your day before you fly, the last flight from EWR to MBJ is with jetBlue at 15:45.

  • To ensure you get on your flight from New York to MBJ, allow plenty of time to check in and find your gate. Turning up two hours ahead of international departures and one hour before domestic flights is the general travel rule.

  • With more travellers during peak months like August, get to the terminal earlier than usual. Two hours for domestic flights and as much as four for international journeys will allow extra time for delays. Remember things also get busy during major holidays like Christmas.

Airports in New York

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)

  • You can take a direct flight from New York to Sangster International Airport (MBJ) departing from Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR).

  • When jetting out of EWR, you can catch a direct flight from New York to Sangster International Airport with jetBlue.

  • A stopover is the ideal opportunity to take a break from travelling — and maybe even tour another city. When searching for flights from New York to MBJ leaving from Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR), deselect the 'Direct flights only' box to see where you can visit along the way. Some popular options include:

    • Charlotte Douglas International Airport (CLT)

    • Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport (ATL)

    • Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International Airport (FLL)

  • From central New York, EWR is around 24 kilometres away. Check the official airport website or use navigation apps to work out the best way to get there.

  • After an easy start to your trip? Stay near Newark Liberty International Airport. Whether you've booked an early flight from New York to Sangster International Airport or just don't like being rushed, these hotels are just the thing:

John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)

  • Want other options for a direct flight from New York to Sangster International Airport (MBJ)? Check out the fares jetting out of John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK).

  • When setting off from JFK, you can choose from a range of airlines that fly straight to your destination. Cruise through the skies on a direct flight from New York to MBJ with one of these:

  • Maximise your holiday with a stopover on your flight from New York to Sangster International Airport. Visit friends or family or tick another city off your list. Whatever your plans, here's where you can stop between John F. Kennedy International Airport and MBJ:

    • Orlando International Airport (MCO)

    • Miami International Airport (MIA)

    • Owen Roberts International Airport (GCM)

  • JFK is about 48 kilometres from central New York. It takes 48 minutes or so to get to the airport if you're driving from the city centre. Public transport takes roughly 1 hour and 20 minutes.

  • It's your holiday, so why not spend another night away? Think about checking in to one of these hotels near John F. Kennedy International Airport the day before your flight from New York to MBJ:

About Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

Getting from Sangster International Airport (MBJ) to central Montego Bay

  • From Sangster International Airport, Montego Bay is approximately 3 kilometres away. It takes around 12 minutes to get to the centre driving.

How to find the cheapest flights from New York to Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

  • Book a one-way ticket from New York to Sangster International Airport from $167 or travel return from just $414. The prices shown are based on availability and could change when you book.

  • 8 months before your departure is the best time to lock in flight tickets from New York to MBJ.

  • You'll land the biggest savings on your tickets from New York to Sangster International Airport if you travel in May. Take it one step further and use the 'Whole month' search tool to find the cheapest day to fly out.

  • Finding a cheap ticket from New York to MBJ couldn't be easier with Price Alerts. Simply create one of these automatic alerts and we'll get in touch as soon as the price drops.

  • Personalise your trip using filters. Choose the total duration, number of stops, and departure and arrival times to find the ideal flight from New York to Sangster International Airport. You can also sort the results to see the 'Best,' 'Cheapest' or 'Fastest' options first.

The best time to fly from New York to Sangster International Airport (MBJ)

  • July is the most popular month for flights from New York to Sangster International Airport. To steer clear of the crowds, head for Montego Bay in May when it's quieter.

  • Think about the type of weather that'll suit your plans for Montego Bay. August is known as the warmest month. Lock in your flights from New York to MBJ during then and you can expect temperatures of between 25ºC and 31ºC.

  • Look for cheap flights from New York to Sangster International Airport in February if you'd rather travel during cooler conditions. Temperatures are at their lowest around then, ranging between 22ºC and 28ºC on average.

More about Montego Bay

Complete your Montego Bay trip with a car rental

  • Finding you a cheap flight from New York to Sangster International Airport isn't the only trick up our sleeve. Check out our car rentals in Montego Bay and explore the city on your own terms. We find deals from trusted car rental companies and put them all in one place. You can instantly compare offers and then book with no fees.

Plan the rest of your trip from New York to Montego Bay

Prices shown on this page are estimated lowest prices only. Found in the last 45 days.