How to find the best hotel deal in Fire Island
Want to find hotel deals as effortlessly as you book flights? Our award-winning search can handle it all. Here's how you can save money and time when searching for your Fire Island hotel.
Save on your Fire Island hotel and unlock a wider selection of stays when you book early. You'll also have extra time to weigh your options and choose the ideal place.
Still, act fast if you spot any last-minute offers. Some places discount their rates right before arrival to avoid having empty rooms. It's more likely this will happen during off-peak season or on quieter days, however.
Flexible with your dates? You could land a better rate. Move your travel window around to discover what deals are available. Prices are typically cheaper midweek and during less popular months.
Avoid the risk of extra fees by searching for stays with free cancellation. If your schedule changes or a better offer shows up, you can easily cancel your booking.
Where to stay in Fire Island
Central Fire Island
To fully enjoy central Fire Island, you'll want to be near the attractions that inspired your visit in the first place. Here are a few standout stays close to the highlights.
The Palms Hotel Fire Island makes exploring a breeze. Around 2 kilometres away, it's a popular stay near Atlantique Beach.
When to go to Fire Island
The weather is worth considering when choosing your travel dates. July brings the warmest conditions, with temperatures reaching a high of 29ºC (84ºF).
The coolest month is January. Expect lows of -4ºC (25ºF).
Search for Fire Island hotels in September to enjoy mostly clear skies. Averaging six days of rain, this is the driest month.
You can expect more rain in January, which gets around eight days of wet weather.
Best hotels in Fire Island
Best budget hotels
Make your travel money go further by choosing from around six budget Fire Island hotels. Ideal for when you want to spend less on the room and more on adventures, these stays come with the basics like Wi-Fi, toiletries, and simple breakfast options.
Courtyard Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex offers comfort that's easy on the wallet. Make use of parking, a safe deposit box and more at this 3-star option.
Best hotels with a pool
Turn up the fun on your trip with a pool. If you choose a city hotel, expect rooftop and indoor options. Resorts? They usually go big with sprawling outdoor setups and maybe even a swim-up bar. Book a pool hotel in Fire Island and jump into your next adventure.
Unwinding by the water is part of the experience at Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex. With an indoor swimming pool, car rental options and a fitness centre, this Fire Island hotel makes it easy to recharge your batteries.
Best pet-friendly hotels
With at least four pet-friendly Fire Island hotels, there's no need to leave your best buddy behind. Many have nearby parks or outdoor areas for exercise, and some even offer extras like chew toys and grooming services. A few house rules may apply, but most places go out of their way to make your furry friend feel welcome.
Check in with your loyal sidekick at Grove Hotel. Take advantage of amenities here like luggage storage and a nightclub.
Let your loyal companion explore alongside you at The Palms Hotel Fire Island. A cash machine and luggage storage are part of what's available at this pet-approved accommodation option.
