Skyscanner

3-star hotels in Fire Island

Find the best 3-star hotel in Fire Island for your dates, by price or preference

Compare 3-star hotel deals across hundreds of providers, all in one place

Look out for 3-star hotels in Fire Island with free cancellation or excellent ratings

Trusted Fire Island hotel providers

See all hotels in Fire Island

Prices may change – pop in your dates for the best estimate. Note that prices are based on previous traveller searches and partner prices.
Prices may change – pop in your dates for the best estimate. Note that prices are based on previous traveller searches and partner prices.
All taxes and fees included
Grove Hotel

4.90 km from city centre

Lowest price we found for this hotel
Booking.com
From
$428

a night

View more hotels

Other travellers loved these 3-star hotels in Fire Island

Rated by travellers as the best in the city, these stays are all full marks for cleanliness, customer service and location.
Grove Hotel
4.90 km from city centre
$428
Per night
Grove Hotel
4.90 km from city centre
$428
Per night
See more

Find a 3-star Fire Island hotel in the heart of the action

Beat the queues at the top Fire Island attractions by staying close to them.

TWA Flight 800 International Memorial

Fire Island Lighthouse

Cupsogue Beach County Park

TWA Flight 800 International Memorial

Fire Island Lighthouse

Cupsogue Beach County Park

3-star hotels in Fire Island: FAQs

You can always cancel or amend your hotel reservation if you need to, but look out for hotels in Fire Island with free cancellation or flexible booking options if you want to protect your money. Some hotels allow you to cancel and get your money back if your plans change.
Of course - the cheapest hotel deal we found within the next seven days is $221 per night. If you need somewhere in the next 24 hours, we've found you somewhere to stay for $1,145 per night.
The average price of a hotel during the week is $382 per night, and the average price on weekends is $555. Overall, it looks like the cheapest day to stay in Fire Island could be Wednesday.
We crunched some numbers on our calendar and found that Wednesday is the cheapest day to stay in Fire Island. And the most expensive day seems to be Saturday
The average price of a 3-star hotel in Fire Island is currently around $335 per night. And the cheapest 3-star hotel we found is $188 per night.

Plan your trip to Fire Island