Compare and save on Shelter Island hotels

Sorry, We don't support stays longer than 30 nights.

Search our map for the best Shelter Island hotels

Use our map to find hotels near the Shelter Island area or attractions you want to visit.

The best Shelter Island hotels. Read the reviews

Feel confident you’ve booked the perfect stay. Read our real guest reviews before you book.

See more hotels

Hotels in Shelter Island

Find hotel deals in Shelter Island, along with apartments, hostels and other accommodation with Skyscanner Hotels. Choose and book from over 3 hotels in Shelter Island or alternatively, compare hotels near popular landmarks, such as , and .

Looking for a specific hotel property in Shelter Island? Then simply enter that property into the search box above.

Need some inspiration on where to stay? Top rated cheap hotels in Shelter Island include Best Western Grandma's Feather Bed, Frontier Suites Airport Hotel, and Best Western Country Lane Inn based on user reviews.

Skyscanner hotels is a fast, free and simple way to organise your stay. In a few clicks you can easily search, compare and book your Shelter Island accommodation by clicking directly through to the hotel or travel agent website. No fees are added to your stay by booking with us.

To get started, simply add your chosen travel dates to the search box above and let us find cheap hotel deals for you. Or alternatively, select from the hotel options above.